Protect Every Tenth of a Percent: Why Tables of Content is Your Ultimate Restaurant Resource
Running an independent restaurant is one of the toughest jobs out there. Between managing front-of-house operations, optimizing kitchen efficiency, controlling costs, and delivering an exceptional guest experience, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. Every decision—big or small—impacts your bottom line. And in an industry where margins are razor-thin, even a tenth of a percent can make a difference.
That’s where Tables of Content comes in. Our mission is simple: to give you the insights, strategies, and tools to take control of your restaurant’s success.
Every Fraction of Profit Matters—We’ll Help You Protect It
Managing your restaurant’s profit margin is like tending a thriving garden. Just as you nurture each plant differently, every aspect of your business requires careful attention.
Consider this: if your restaurant generates $1M annually, protecting just 0.1% of profit equals $10,000 per year. That’s why Tables of Content exists—to help you safeguard every fraction of profit through smart strategies, industry insights, and actionable tools.
Expert Strategies & Insights
- Master financial management, operations, labor costs, compliance, and guest experience.
- Learn how to optimize pricing, monitor costs, and streamline scheduling to improve profitability.
- Stay ahead with Weekly Wisdom Drops and exclusive monthly newsletters.
Resources for Every Challenge
- Download checklists, templates, and guides covering inventory, hiring, scheduling, and more.
- Discover creative ways to reduce waste, maximize efficiency, and refine service models.
Exclusive Forum Access
- Connect with fellow independent restaurateurs and get real-world advice on everyday challenges.
- Exchange ideas, troubleshoot problems, and learn from those who’ve been in your shoes.
Hands-On Profit Protection
- Control food & beverage costs: Smart inventory management, supplier negotiations, and portion control techniques.
- Manage labor effectively: Cross-training, efficient scheduling, and payroll tracking to protect your margins.
- Optimize operations: Streamlined workflows, strategic floor layouts, and technology solutions to boost efficiency.
- Enhance the guest experience: From staff training to menu strategy, we’ll help you increase customer satisfaction—and revenue.
Built for Independent Restaurants—Not Corporate Chains
Whether you’re a chef-owner, bar manager, front-of-house lead, or multi-tasking operator, Tables of Content is designed for restaurants like yours. We offer guidance tailored to small, independent establishments, from neighborhood bistros to family-owned eateries.
Unlike one-size-fits-all industry resources, we focus on real-world solutions that work for independent restaurants—not just big chains with corporate backing.
Why Invest and Subscribe?
Every dollar counts in this industry, and we get that. That’s why Tables of Content is affordable and packed with value.
Your subscription unlocks:
- Expert blog posts covering everything from financial strategy to guest experience.
- Downloadable tools & templates to save time and streamline your operations.
- Actionable industry insights delivered straight to your inbox every week.
- A community of restaurant professionals sharing real-world solutions and support.
For a limited time, you can be a Foundation Member, where for just $3 per month, you’ll gain access to everything you need to run a smarter, more profitable restaurant.
Join a Community of Restaurant Professionals Committed to Success
Independent restaurant owners, operators, and managers across the country trust Tables of Content to help them increase efficiency, reduce costs, and grow sustainably.
If you’re ready to take control of your restaurant’s future, join us today. Your margins—and your peace of mind—will thank you.
If you enjoyed this article and would like to read more
Tax Prep Pitfalls: Set Your CPA up for Success
Tax season is a lot like a surprise health inspection: technically not a surprise, but it still feels that way if you have not prepared. For restaurants, the pain usually comes from one thing: disorganized information. Your CPA can only work with what you hand them. If it is incomplete, late, or messy, you pay for it in time, stress, and sometimes penalties.
This isn’t a how-to-file-your-taxes guide. It’s a practical checklist of what to organize in advance so your accountant can move fast, ask better questions, and help you legally minimize what you owe.
Think of it as mise en place for your books.
1. Make sure your books for the year are actually closed
Before you start pulling fancy reports, confirm the basics: is last year’s bookkeeping done?
At minimum, you want:
- All bank and credit card accounts reconciled through year-end.
- All deposits recorded and categorized (sales, loans, owner contributions, etc.).
- All expenses entered and reasonably categorized (COGS, labor, rent, utilities, repairs, etc.).
- Any major one-off items clearly labeled (equipment purchases, buildout costs, legal fees, etc.).
If your books are behind, prioritize reconciling bank and credit card accounts first. That gives you a skeleton of what really happened cash-wise, even if some categories are still a bit fuzzy. Your CPA will do much better work with “mostly right but categorized simply” than with a year of missing transactions and guesswork.
If you’re using an accounting system like QuickBooks, Xero, or restaurant-focused platforms integrated with your POS, this is where you spend time cleaning, not reinventing.
2. Confirm your chart of accounts makes sense for a restaurant
If your chart of accounts looks like it was borrowed from a generic small business template, tax prep gets harder and performance analysis is useless.
You want a structure that:
- Separates food, beverage, and other COGS.
- Separates front-of-house and back-of-house labor where possible.
- Breaks out major fixed costs (rent, CAM, insurance, utilities, licenses).
- Clearly distinguishes repairs and maintenance from capital improvements.
You do not have to rebuild everything right before tax season, but you should at least:
- Clean up obviously mis-categorized expenses (wine in “office supplies,” anyone?).
- Flag any large, weird-looking entries you’re not sure how to treat.
Make a short list of “classification questions” for your CPA: things like “Is this new oven a full deduction or does it need to be depreciated?” or “Where should we classify our delivery platform fees?” That conversation is much faster when you’ve done some pre-sorting.
3. Organize your payroll and tip information
Payroll is one of the most sensitive pieces of your tax picture, especially in restaurants.
Make sure:
- Your payroll processor has correct, current information for all employees (names, addresses, Social Security/Tax IDs).
- All pay runs for the year have been processed and posted to your books.
- Tips, service charges, and any auto-gratuities are properly recorded and reported in your system.
You’ll want year-to-date reports that show:
- Total wages by employee and by type (regular, overtime).
- Reported tips and any allocated tips.
- Employer payroll taxes and benefits (if applicable).
Your CPA will need these to reconcile W-2s and ensure tip reporting and payroll taxes align with what is showing on your books.
If you changed payroll providers mid-year, gather reports from both systems. That switch is a common spot where totals go missing.
4. Gather your 1099-related information
If you pay non-employees for services (contractors, some entertainers, certain consultants, possibly some landlord or vendor situations depending on structure), you may need to issue Forms 1099. Your accountant will guide you on who qualifies, but you can make their life easier by preparing:
- A list of all non-employee payees with names, addresses, and Tax ID numbers (from W-9 forms).
- Total amounts paid to each during the year, broken out by type if needed.
If you did not collect W-9s upfront, this is your reminder to make that a standard part of onboarding any independent contractor. It is much easier to ask for a form before you’ve paid someone than to chase it down after year-end.
5. Inventory, COGS, and shrink: have your ending numbers ready
For tax purposes and for your own sanity, you’ll want a clean picture of:
- Beginning inventory for the year (or opening date if you’re newer).
- Purchases during the year.
- Ending inventory at year-end.
That’s what feeds your cost of goods sold calculation.
If you’re not doing a full physical count at the end of the year, strongly consider it. Even a simplified count on major categories (meat, seafood, liquor, wine, beer, dry goods) is better than guessing. It gives your CPA a defensible number and helps you see how well your theoretical food and bev costs match reality.
If you had any major write-offs (spoilage from an outage, inventory loss from a walk-in failure, theft, etc.), document those events with:
- Date, approximate value, and reason.
- Any supporting notes or photos you have.
Your accountant can advise on how those losses should be treated, but only if they know they exist.
6. Pull key documents and contracts into one place
Digging through old email chains and file folders is what makes tax prep feel endless. Spend an hour gathering the important documents your CPA will likely ask for so they’re all in one folder (physical or digital).
Typical items:
- Lease agreement and any amendments.
- Loan documents and year-end loan statements.
- Equipment purchase invoices for major items.
- Insurance policies (especially liability and workers’ comp) and proof of premium payments.
- Any grant, relief, or special funding documentation if you’ve received it in the year.
If you opened, expanded, or remodeled during the year, include construction contracts, buildout invoices, and any permits or fees you paid. Those often have tax implications around capitalization and depreciation.
7. Don’t forget sales tax and local obligations
Income tax is only one part of the picture. In many locations, you also have:
- Sales tax on food and/or beverage.
- Liquor-specific taxes or fees.
- Local business licenses and health department fees.
Make sure your sales tax filings and payments are up to date or at least reconciled. Your CPA does not want to discover during income tax prep that there’s also a lurking sales tax problem.
If you are behind on any of these, be upfront about it. It’s better to build a plan with your accountant than to let notices pile up in a drawer.
8. Make a list of questions and planned changes
Tax season is also your once-a-year “office hours” with a professional who sees a lot of restaurants. Don’t waste the time.
Before you meet or send your package, jot down:
- Any upcoming big decisions (new location, expansion, major equipment, ownership changes, new delivery channels).
- Any pain points from last year’s tax experience (“We got surprised by X,” “We didn’t understand Y”).
- Specific goals, like “We want to set aside for quarterly taxes more consistently,” or “We want cleaner books so we can actually read our numbers monthly.”
This gives your CPA context and usually leads to better advice than “here are my numbers, what do I owe?”
9. Package it like you respect their time (and your billable hours)
Once you have everything, spend a little time on presentation. You don’t need to be fancy; you just need to be clear.
For example:
- One folder or shared drive with subfolders: “Financials,” “Payroll,” “1099/W-9,” “Loans & Lease,” “Inventory,” “Other Docs.”
- A simple cover sheet or email that summarizes: revenue, number of locations, any big changes from last year, and anything unusual they should know upfront.
You are making it easy for your CPA to work efficiently. That tends to show up on your invoice.
Pulling it together
Tax season will never be fun, but it doesn’t have to be chaotic. If you close your books, organize payroll and 1099 information, document inventory and big events, and gather your key contracts and statements, you walk into that conversation with real control.
Block a couple of sessions on the calendar with your manager or bookkeeper, treat them like important prep time, and get your financial mise en place together before you hit “send” to your CPA. Future you – and your spring cash flow – will be a lot less stressed.
If you enjoyed this article and would like to read more
Keeping Delivery and Takeout Safe in Snow, Rain, and Ice
When the weather gets ugly, a lot of guests trade bar stools for couch cushions and start ordering in. That can be a great revenue offset for slow dining rooms, but bad-weather delivery also magnifies your risk: slick sidewalks, dark parking lots, rushed handoffs, and food riding around in freezing air.
If you treat bad weather deliveries as its own service mode, you can keep people safer and protect food quality while everyone else is winging it.
Decide When You’re Actually “On” for Delivery
The most important decision is not which bag you use. It’s whether you’re delivering at all.
Before the season starts, define what different levels of weather mean for your operation. For example:
- Light rain: normal delivery radius and times.
- Heavy rain or snow: smaller radius and longer quoted times.
- Ice storms or severe alerts: pickup only, no drivers on the road.
Pick who has the authority to flip those switches and how they’ll communicate it to staff and guests. The goal is to avoid arguing about safety at 6 p.m. while the radar looks like a disaster.
Make It Safer for Drivers
You cannot control the whole roads, but you can control the conditions in and around your building and the expectations you set.
For in-house drivers, set clear standards: non-slip footwear, use of insulated delivery bags that actually zip, and a company line that no order is worth speeding for. Keep basic gear near the driver entrance: ice melt, a shovel in winter, decent umbrellas, high-visibility vests or outerwear. Vendors like Grainger are good sources for non-slip and hi-vis gear plus safety signage.
If you lean on third-party drivers, focus on your end of the handoff. Keep pickup areas dry, well-lit, and clearly marked. Make sure they can find the right door quickly instead of wandering in the rain, dripping through the dining room to ask where to go.
Fix the Dangerous Spots on Your Property
Most incidents involving delivery and takeout cluster in a few spots: curb edges, ramps, and the path from your door to the parking area.
Walk those routes after a storm or heavy rain:
- Do puddles form right where people step out?
- Does the ramp get slick when it’s wet?
- Are there dark patches between the door and the lot?
- Where do drivers naturally park or wait?
Once you see it, you can act: non-slip mats at entrances, better lighting over the main path, a clearly marked pickup space you keep salted or swept, wet floor signs where people cross tile with wet shoes. These changes help guests, staff, and drivers all at once.
Package for Weather, Not Just Aesthetics
Storms are tough on food. Cold air and bumpy rides kill temperature; trapped steam kills texture.
Stress-test your current packaging:
- Does it leak when it’s jostled or gets a bit of rain on it?
- Do crispy items arrive soggy?
- Do hot and cold items ride in the same steamy box?
Where you can, upgrade to vented containers for fried items, separate hot and cold into different bags, and standardize the use of insulated delivery bags in bad weather. For very wet days, an extra outer paper bag can keep things from arriving soaked.
It helps to have a short “storm mode” packaging SOP so the team knows what to grab without debating every order.
Clean Up Staging and Handoff
Ugly weather magnifies any chaos in your pickup area. Drivers and guests want in and out, not a scavenger hunt.
Audit your setup:
- Are orders clearly organized by platform and time, or in a pile?
- Is the actual handoff spot blocking the door?
- Are guests and drivers constantly asking, “where do I go?”
Simple fixes do a lot: labeled shelves or zones by app, a dedicated spot for direct orders, and a handoff point a few steps away from the main flow so wet coats and dripping umbrellas aren’t clogging the entrance.
Quote Honest Times and Stick to Them
Nothing encourages risky driving like unrealistic promise times.
In bad weather, add buffer into your KDS or POS, widen delivery windows in your apps, and reduce your delivery radius if needed. Train whoever controls the tablets and phones to make those adjustments proactively.
It is better to quote 55 minutes and hit it than promise 30 and force drivers to choose between speeding and being late.
Communicate Clearly When Storms Hit
Guests are usually reasonable when the forecast is obviously ugly, but only if you keep them informed.
Decide ahead of time how you will announce:
- Switched-off delivery or reduced zones.
- Longer waits.
- Pickup-only periods.
Use a mix of website messaging, quick social posts, and clear notes on third-party platforms. On the phone, a simple line works: “We’re open and happy to cook for you, but because of the weather our delivery times are running a bit longer than usual. Pickup will be faster if that’s an option for you.”
Transparency turns most complaints into understanding.
Build a One-Page Weather Playbook
You do not need a big manual. A single page is enough:
- Weather levels and what each one triggers.
- Who decides and who communicates.
- Any changes to delivery radius, packaging, and quoted times.
- Basic safety expectations for drivers and staff.
Review it at the start of the season, then briefly before any big storm that’s clearly coming.
Handled this way, inclement weather becomes a controlled variation of your service instead of a scramble. Drivers stay safer, the food arrives closer to how you intended, and guests feel like you are prepared for the weather, not surprised by it.
If you enjoyed this article and would like to read more
How to Turn January’s Slow Weeks into Training and Project Wins
January can feel like punishment after the holiday rush. The books are quieter, guests are often dialing back spending, and staff energy is weird: half-relieved, half-worried about hours.
You can treat that lull as dead time, or you can turn it into an annual reset where you finally tackle the stuff you never have time for in Q4: training, systems, and the “we should fix that someday” projects.
The trick is to plan for it like a season, not a surprise.
Decide what January is for
Start simple: pick two or three things you want noticeably better by March. Maybe that’s faster ticket times, a more confident bar team, a saner storage system, or smoother host flow.
Write those priorities down and treat them like guardrails. When new ideas pop up – and they will – you can ask, “Does this actually help one of our January priorities?” If not, it goes on the parking lot list for later.
Build a schedule that leaves room to improve
When sales drop, it’s easy to slash the schedule so hard that nobody has energy or stability for anything extra.
Instead, build a realistic baseline first: enough coverage for actual demand, enough hours that your core people don’t panic, and a couple of predictable windows each week you can use for training or projects. That might mean shorter operating hours on certain days or closing one slower night to consolidate traffic.
Once those anchors are set, you can plug in one or two 60–90 minute blocks a week for development when people are already in the building and not buried.
Make training feel useful, not like homework
If training means reading policies in a circle, you’ll lose everyone immediately.
Use January for skills that make shifts smoother and checks bigger. For front-of-house, that could be a focused menu and upsell session with real tastings, or short role-plays on handling large parties, complaints, and “make it right” moments. For back-of-house, it might be deepening one fragile station, tightening knife skills while knocking out real prep, or finally standardizing the recipes everyone’s been free-styling.
Keep it practical, time-bound, and tied to real service. End each session with something concrete: a new cheat sheet, a clarified plating standard, a cleaner station layout.
Choose a few projects and actually finish them
January is where half-finished projects love to die. The solution is fewer, better targets.
Pick a small handful of projects you can close in two to four weeks and that everyone will feel during service: reorganizing dry storage or walk-ins, cleaning up host and reservation flow, fixing dish and smallwares storage so plates stop migrating around the building.
Give each project an owner, a clear scope, and a finish line. When one is done, show the before-and-after. People are more willing to jump into the next thing when they’ve just seen one win all the way through.
Use the lull to test changes while the stakes are lower
January is the perfect sandbox.
Because volume is softer, you can try things that would feel risky in June: shifting where certain tickets print, tweaking how expo calls the board, changing the order of greet / drink / order / check, or running a small winter menu that leans on shared prep and better cross-utilization.
Watch the effect on both guests and the line. If something clearly works, write it into your standard playbook. If it doesn’t, you’ve learned cheaply and can move on.
Let emerging leaders run something real
Slow weeks are a great way to see who’s ready for more responsibility without throwing them straight into a Saturday night fire drill.
Ask a strong server to design and run one training session with guidance. Have a line cook lead the walk-in reset. Let a host or shift lead own a new pre-shift format for a week. You’re looking for planning, communication, and follow-through, not perfection.
By the end of the month, you’ll have a clearer sense of who’s ready for trainer, lead, or assistant roles when the volume returns.
Make January feel intentional, not alarming
If all your staff see is empty sections and shorter shifts, they’ll assume the worst and start looking elsewhere.
Frame the month clearly: why it’s slower, what you’re choosing to work on, how you’re trying to protect core hours, and how the training and projects will make their lives easier when you’re slammed again. Share the training calendar. Post the project list. Call out the wins as they land.
Do this every year and “slow January” stops feeling like punishment. It becomes the built-in time you tune the machine, grow your people, and fix the stuff that always breaks at the worst possible moment.
If you enjoyed this article and would like to read more
1099s, W-2s, and Tip Reporting: A Practical Guide
Payroll in restaurants is already complicated. Then January hits and suddenly you’re staring at an alphabet soup of forms and deadlines: W-2s, 1099s, tip reports, payroll summaries, maybe a panicked email from your accountant.
This isn’t a legal treatise on U.S. tax law, and specifics can change by year and by jurisdiction. It is a practical operator’s guide to what these forms do, what information they need from you, and how to avoid the most common “we should have caught this months ago” headaches.
Use it with a good CPA or payroll provider, not instead of one.
W-2s: the story of your employees’ year
W-2s go to people who are on your payroll as employees. That includes servers, bartenders, cooks, dishwashers, hosts, managers, and often you, if you’re paying yourself through payroll.
Your payroll provider usually generates and files W-2s, but they can only work with clean data. Your job is to make sure:
- Everyone is set up correctly. Legal names, addresses, and Social Security numbers are accurate. New hires are in the system, and terminated employees are properly marked as inactive.
- All pay is in payroll. No side checks, cash “bonuses,” or under-the-table hours that never made it into the system. If someone worked, they should be in your payroll history.
- Year-to-date totals reconcile. Wages, reported tips, and employer taxes in your payroll reports match what hit your bank and your books.
If any of this is messy, you don’t fix it in March. You find it when you run the final payroll of the year, or in an early-January review with your payroll provider.
1099s: paying non-employees
1099 forms go to people or entities you pay who aren’t on payroll as employees, but meet certain criteria under tax rules. Think: some entertainers, freelance marketers or designers, a consultant who helped you with a project, maybe the photographer who shoots your dishes.
You don’t decide who gets a 1099 purely on vibes. The IRS and local rules define who qualifies. What you cando is make life easier by building good habits:
- Collect a W-9 up front. Any time you’re going to pay a non-employee for services, get a completed W-9 before you send the first check. That gives you their legal name, address, and Tax ID.
- Pay them consistently. Use the same vendor name in your accounting system every time, so you can easily pull total payments at year-end.
- Tag the right vendors. Ask your accountant or bookkeeper which vendor types in your system should be reviewed for 1099s each year.
Your accountant (or a robust payroll/HR platform) will usually run the final numbers and generate 1099s. Your job is to make sure the vendor list and totals are right so they aren’t guessing who got what.
If you’re using third-party delivery platforms or online ordering systems, ask your CPA how those relationships are treated for 1099/1099-K purposes. The rules and thresholds have shifted in recent years, and you want them, not you, making the call on how to report platform payouts.
Tips: the part restaurants most often get in trouble on
Tips are unique. They affect employee wages, payroll tax, and sometimes your eligibility for certain tax credits. They’re also where a lot of informal “we’ve always done it this way” practices live.
There are three big buckets to pay attention to:
- Tip reporting by employees
- Servers and bartenders are required to report tips to you, not just to keep them. Your POS should capture credit-card tips automatically, and you need a reliable way to record cash tips.
- Make sure staff understand that accurate reporting protects them too: it ties to their W-2, Social Security, and future credit/loan applications.
- How tips, service charges, and “auto-grats” are different
- Voluntary tips from guests are treated one way for payroll and tax purposes.
- Mandatory service charges (like a 20% “service fee” you add to all checks, or banquet fees) are treated differently. They’re usually business revenue first, not tips straight to staff, even if you share them.
- That difference affects how you run them through payroll, whether they count toward tip credit (where applicable), and how they show up on W-2s.
- Tip pools and sharing
- If you pool tips across servers, bartenders, bussers, and possibly back-of-house, you need to align your structure with current law where you operate.
- Some jurisdictions limit who can participate in a pool, especially if you’re using a lower “tipped minimum wage” or tip credit.
This is one of the most common areas where a short conversation with an HR/payroll pro or CPA saves you a lot of future pain. Bring them your actual process, not your idealized version, and say: “Is this still compliant here?”
How these pieces interact in real life
On paper, W-2s, 1099s, and tip reports are separate topics. In practice, they touch each other constantly.
Typical scenarios:
- A server’s W-2 doesn’t match their expectations because reported tips were lower than what they actually earned. That points to problems in daily tip entry or pooling records.
- You get a letter about under-reported payroll taxes because tip income wasn’t fully captured in payroll, even though it was paid out.
- A contractor is surprised by a 1099 because you never collected a W-9, paid them sporadically under slightly different names, and they forgot how much the totals added up to.
All of this feels like “forms trouble,” but it started with day-to-day systems: how you set people up, how you record payments, how you handle tips, and how disciplined you are with vendor records.
A simple annual rhythm that keeps you out of the ditch
You don’t need to become a tax expert. You do need a basic rhythm.
Once a year, ideally in December or very early January:
- Run a payroll and tips check-up.
Confirm that employee information is clean, that year-to-date wages and tips look right, and that your tip reporting process still matches your model (tipped wage vs full minimum, service charges, pooling). - Review your vendor list with a 1099 lens.
With your accountant, identify which vendors might need 1099s, confirm you have W-9s on file, and clean up duplicate or misnamed entries. - Document what you actually do.
Write a one-page summary: how employees report tips, how you handle service charges, who is in your tip pool, and how you pay non-employees. Share it with your CPA and ask, “Does anything here make you nervous for this year?” - Set reminders for next year.
Add “collect W-9s before first payment” and “review tip process with managers” to your onboarding and policy checklist so you’re not reinventing this every January.
The payoff
Handled badly, W-2s, 1099s, and tip reporting are just stress, surprise bills, and awkward emails from former staff. Handled well, they become one more system you understand and manage, instead of something that happens to you.
You still want a professional doing the actual filings. But if you give them organized, accurate information and a clear picture of how your restaurant really runs, they can protect you, find efficiencies, and free you up manage your day to day business.
If you enjoyed this article and would like to read more
Recalibrating Your Menu Prices for the New Year
You’ve survived the holiday crush, your food and labor costs have probably crept up, and your menu prices are often a season or two behind reality.
Repricing is uncomfortable, so it gets delayed. You tweak here, comp there, and hope volume will save you. It usually doesn’t.
A New Year reset is a natural moment to bring your menu back in line with actual costs and the experience you’re delivering. The key is to do it with intention instead of slapping on “a couple of bucks” across the board.
Start with what your menu really costs now
Before you touch a price, you need a current snapshot of plate cost. Otherwise you’re just guessing.
Pick your top sellers first: the dishes that drive volume and define who you are. For each one, pull:
- Current vendor prices on every ingredient
- Standard recipe quantities and yields
- Realistic portion sizes, not “ideal” ones from when you opened
Run the math and get a current food cost per plate. Do the same for your key beverages: house cocktails, by-the-glass wines, draft beers.
You don’t need to cost every single item before you move, but you do want to understand:
- Which items are margin heroes, quietly carrying the menu
- Which ones have drifted into “we’re basically giving this away” territory
That alone will change how you think about your pricing conversation.
Decide what “good” looks like before you raise a single price
If you skip this step, you’ll end up nudging numbers without a real target.
Align with your leadership team on a few simple questions:
- What’s our target food cost percentage overall, and on key categories?
- Are there items we’ll accept at a lower margin because they are true traffic drivers?
- Are there items that should be higher-margin to balance the mix?
Maybe you decide, for example, that core entrees should sit around a certain cost percentage, that a signature dish can be a little leaner because it’s your calling card, and that indulgent add-ons (extra toppings, premium sides, upgrades) will carry stronger margin.
Write that logic down. You’re not just “raising prices.” You’re moving the menu toward a clear economic shape.
Make it strategic, not reactionary
Across-the-board increases are easy, but they’re rarely the smartest move. Guests don’t notice a 3–4% change evenly; they notice where perceived value breaks.
Start with three types of adjustments:
- Patch the obvious leaks.
That entrée where the cost jumped 15% and the price never moved? The cocktail where the garnish now costs as much as the spirit pour? Fix those first. Bring them back into a sane margin range, even if it means a noticeable bump. - Nudge the middle.
For solid, everyday items, smaller, more uniform increases often work: 50 cents here, a dollar there, especially on things where the perceived value is still strong. - Audit portion vs. price.
In some cases, the problem isn’t the sticker; it’s the serving. If your plate looks generous enough to feed two, you may be able to slightly reduce portion size and adjust price, keeping value intact while protecting cost.
Be thoughtful about psychological thresholds. Jumping a beloved burger from $18 to $23 in one shot is going to be felt. Sometimes you’re better off pairing a price increase with a small value-add (better side, slight upgrade in product) or moving in two steps over a season.
Look at the menu holistically
Once you’ve made your draft changes, step back and view the menu as a guest would.
Questions to ask:
- Does the pricing ladder still make sense? Are there clear “good, better, best” steps in each category?
- Is there an obvious “hero” in each section that feels like a strong value, even after adjustments?
- Are you unintentionally pushing everything up so tightly that guests feel there’s no approachable option?
Think about anchoring. A couple of higher-priced, high-value items can make the rest of the menu feel reasonable. If all your entrees live in the same narrow band, guests have no price-based way to navigate.
This is also a good moment to quietly retire underperformers that are too expensive to make or too confusing to explain. Price changes land easier when the menu also gets a little sharper and more focused.
Bring your team into the “why,” not just the “what”
Servers, bartenders, and hosts are the ones who hear the first “Wow, that went up.” They need context.
Before you launch the updated menu, gather the team and explain:
- What’s changed and where (in plain language, not a spreadsheet)
- Why certain items moved more than others
- Where the strongest values are now, so they know what to recommend confidently
Give them language that feels honest and calm. Something like:
“We’ve updated a few prices for the New Year to keep up with ingredient, labor, and rent increases. We’ve focused on protecting portions and quality, and there are still great value options in every section.”
If staff believe the menu is still fair and intentional, they can stand behind it. If they feel blindsided, they’ll unconsciously apologize for your pricing, which is not where you want to be.
Launch and analyze
Recalibrating prices isn’t a one-and-done move. The first few weeks after a change tell you whether your theory holds up.
Track, even loosely:
- How your key items are selling relative to before
- Whether check averages move the way you expected
- If guests are suddenly migrating away from one specific dish because the price no longer feels right
Listen to what servers are hearing at the table. One or two comments aren’t data, but if everyone is suddenly getting pushback on the same item, that’s a signal.
You can always make small, targeted corrections: adjust one price down a touch, sweeten a value proposition, or rebalance how you talk about the menu. The point is to iterate, not to freeze.
Make it a rhythm
Repricing is hardest when you haven’t done it in years. Costs jump, your prices jump, and everybody feels it.
If you build a light pricing review into your annual or semiannual cadence, you’re doing gentle course corrections instead of emergency surgery. A New Year recalibration is a great anchor: look at your real costs, tune the menu, explain the changes, and monitor the impact.
Handled this way, price changes feel less like a shock and more purposeful: protecting margin so you can keep paying your team, sourcing good product, and cooking the food your guests actually love.
If you enjoyed this article and would like to read more